There are a number of reasons why it might be better to choose a
commercial, or another free Prolog system:
- SWI-Prolog comes with no warranties
Although the developers or the community often provide a work-around or
a fix for a bug, there is no place you can go to for guaranteed support.
However, the full source archive is available and can be used to compile
and debug SWI-Prolog using free tools on all major platforms. Depending
users should ensure access to knowledgeable developers.
- Performance is your first concern
Various free and commercial systems have better performance. But,
`standard' Prolog benchmarks disregard many factors that are often
critical to the performance of large applications. SWI-Prolog is not
good at fast calling of simple predicates and if-then-else selection
based on simple built-in tests, but it is fast with dynamic code,
meta-calling and predicates that contain large numbers of clauses. Many
of SWI-Prolog's built-in predicates are written in C and have excellent
performance.
- You need features not offered by SWI-Prolog
Although SWI-Prolog has many features, it also lacks some important
features. The most well know is probably tabling
Freire et
al., 1997. If you require additional features and you
have resources, being it financial or expertise, please contact the
developers.
On the other hand, SWI-Prolog offers some facilities that are widely
appreciated by users:
- Nice environment
SWI-Prolog provides a good commandline environment, including `Do What I
Mean', autocompletion, history and a tracer that operates on single
key-strokes. The system automatically recompiles modifies parts of the
source code using the make/0
command. The system can be instructed to open an arbitrary editor on the
right file and line based on its source database. In ships with various
graphical tools and can be combined with SWI-Prolog editor, PDT (Eclipse
plugin for Prolog) or GNU-Emacs.
- Fast compiler
Even very large applications can be loaded in seconds on most machines.
If this is not enough, there is the Quick Load Format. See qcompile/1
and qsave_program/2.
- Transparent compiled code
SWI-Prolog compiled code can be treated just as interpreted code: you
can list it, trace it, etc. This implies you do not have to decide
beforehand whether a module should be loaded for debugging or not and
the performance of debugged code is close to that of normal operation.
- Source level debugger
The source level debugger provides a good overview of your current
location in the search tree, variable bindings, your source code and
open choicepoints. Choicepoint inspection provide meaningful insight to
both novices and experienced users. Avoiding unintended choicepoints
often provides a huge increase in performance and a huge saving in
memory usage.
- Profiling
SWI-Prolog offers an execution profiler with either textual output or
graphical output. Finding and improving hotspots in a Prolog program may
result in huge speedups.
- Flexibility
SWI-Prolog can easily be integrated with C, supporting non-determinism
in Prolog calling C as well as C calling Prolog (see section
9). It can also be embedded in external programs (see
section 9.5). System predicates can
be redefined locally to provide compatibility with other Prolog systems.
- Threads
Robust support for multiple threads may improve performance and is a key
enabling factor for deploying Prolog in server applications.
- Interfaces
SWI-Prolog ships with many extension packages that provide robust
interfaces to processes, encryption, TCP/IP, TIPC, ODBC, SGML/XML/HTML,
RDF, HTTP, graphics and much more.
